Yes, subjective for sure, for my money I have never seen Josh use footwork to wrongfoot a defender. You know what he will do if he can't burn them on the outside, he cuts back in and takes the contact. Reliable, safe, and yes no bad decisions. You know he will pop up looking for work, but that is not going to displace some of the wingers from their teams, who have players who can dance their way through and maybe a fraction more pace.
I presume you mean Robson of last year?Most would agree, me too. This year, not so much. Interesting you mention De Klerk, I actually would not want a de Klerk figure here- great player for the type of rugby I don't want to see. Such a vastly different player I cannot really compare. If you stuck De K into our 2917 vintage, it would have been a disaster. Horses for courses.
Agree on selection of Paulo too.