Always a Wasp

Author Topic: Guardian - Kitson's Blog (a must read)  (Read 1312 times)

Neils

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 14807
  • Wasps Rugby Fan
    • View Profile
Guardian - Kitson's Blog (a must read)
« on: October 18, 2022, 09:30:09 AM »
Sad implosion of Wasps and Worcester must be warning call for English rugby

The sport’s days of reckoning are here, and everyone from the RFU to reckless club owners is responsible for the pain
Robert Kitson
Robert Kitson
Sat 15 Oct 2022 20.00 BST
Last modified on Sat 15 Oct 2022 20.47 BST

We could start with the sheer catastrophic waste of it all. All those years, all those hundreds of millions of pounds squandered. All the fudged decisions and fingers‑crossed accounting. The oceans of bullshit, the overflowing reservoirs of self‑interest. And yet that’s still not the most upsetting element. Worse is the numbing pain for everyone associated with two disintegrating clubs and the human cost of English rugby’s days of reckoning.

There will be some looking at the travails of Wasps and Worcester and giving a resigned shrug. Of course they were spending beyond their means. Of course that couldn’t go on indefinitely. Of course fingers should be pointed at the stewardship of both businesses. But fundamentally this is about people – specifically the umpteen players, coaches, staff and fans let down by those meant to have their best interests at heart.


A touch emotive? Damn right. Decades ago, I was a frequent visitor to Wasps’ old home at Repton Avenue in Sudbury and grew to recognise many of the qualities that define a great rugby club. Wasps didn’t have much but they were the most welcoming club in London.

They didn’t mind where you came from or care what you did for a living. Instead they chose to operate on the refreshing basis that generosity of spirit costs nothing. Which is why, when they won all those big shiny trophies in the professional era, there was such a feelgood vibe attached.

Worcester Warriors were less successful on the field but were totally embedded in their community. The late Cecil Duckworth poured his heart and soul into the place and the bond between players and fans remained strong right to the end. So to reach a point where other teams are starting to pick at the entrails of both clubs’ horror‑stricken squads and greedily eyeing extra slices of P-share pie is genuinely sad and an appalling look for the English game as a whole.

Again, we all knew it was potentially coming. Remember that classic old cartoon where Wile E Coyote is nudged over a cliff by Road Runner and is briefly suspended in mid-air before gravity takes over? When costs and wages rise more steeply than revenue, a sharp descent inevitably follows. The tragedy – and for once it is appropriate to use that word in this context – of Wasps and Worcester is that this essential truth was not addressed years ago.

Before things can move forward, consequently, Premiership Rugby and the Rugby Football Union must collectively accept that dodgy owners, Covid-19, the dominance of Premier League football, concussion concerns and the cost of living crisis are not, ultimately, what has precipitated the current mess. If those in charge now cannot be blamed for longstanding governance failings, some of their predecessors should be experiencing deep shame.

Those of us who reported on the demise of Richmond and London Scottish in 1999 are certainly entitled to ask why decent folk are still being so brutally shafted. I have never forgotten asking Bristol’s then director of rugby, Peter Thorburn, how he felt as his club neared financial meltdown in 2003. “It’s no use worrying about it, not in public anyway. You do that in bed at night,” the seasoned Kiwi said. “I was quite proud of the fact I had bugger-all grey hair when I came over. I’ve gone a bit greyer now.”

The majority of clubs would have disappeared long ago without the generosity of benefactors well aware they would never see a penny of profit in return. But where were the checks and balances regarding potential new owners, the insistence on sound, fully costed business plans or a concerted desire to strengthen the league’s weakest commercial links? All are now being proposed, with the stable door wide open and the horse already miles over the horizon.

A penny, too, for the thoughts of the private equity bods at CVC, with their £200m Premiership investment not going terribly well. The Premiership “reset” now being talked about, possibly involving a 10-club league from 2024, does at least open up some possibilities, particularly as CVC has already lobbed more than £150m at the United Rugby Championship and £365m at the Six Nations. At last club games and internationals might just dovetail nicely, the season structure could cease to be a dog’s dinner and the top players would no longer be routinely flogged.


But we have been highlighting those same issues for more than two decades. Ditto the need for a more vibrant domestic second tier, in which young English playing and coaching talent can be properly developed. It already seems inconceivable the proposed salary cap increase to £6.4m (from £5m) in 2024-25 can proceed, with player wages set to become more closely linked to revenue.

The RFU chief executive, Bill Sweeney, along with seeing a 10-team Premiership as correcting “a lot of things that have been wrong for a long time” told the Telegraph that the French model – where clubs have to prove their funding is solid before the season starts – was of interest. Bear in mind, as an aside, that France’s broadcast deal with Canal+ is worth about £98m a year, compared with the £37m the English clubs receive from BT Sport.


With an ominous financial wind now blowing through all sectors of the economy, the only hope is that the implosion of two fine clubs finally concentrates a few more minds. “There’s deep sadness for people at Wasps and Worcester but let’s use this as an opportunity to build a longer-lasting future,” said Nigel Melville, who now represents the English club investors.

The days when English rugby union could blithely ignore the basic rules of business have gone for ever.
Let me tell you something cucumber

BlackAndGoldSunglasses

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 368
  • Wasps Rugby Fan
    • View Profile
Re: Guardian - Kitson's Blog (a must read)
« Reply #1 on: October 18, 2022, 10:27:36 AM »
Also from Kitson, in todays "The Breakdown" email:

Jack Willis offers RFU chance to test whether central contracts can work

After being made redundant by Wasps, the England flanker could be a catalyst for RFU to take back control of players

Viewed through the narrow prism of current events, one name leaps off England’s squad list for the autumn series. A penny for poor Jack Willis’s thoughts as he seeks to balance playing at the highest level with being made redundant at Wasps. Suddenly, he is also that rarest of unicorns: an English international primarily employed by his national union, not his club.

Forget about central contracts being a future possibility because in effect they are already here. If the Rugby Football Union really wanted to be bold it would jump in and offer Willis – and possibly one or two of his Wasps clubmates – a retainer until next year’s World Cup. Followed by other players once the eight-year professional game agreement expires in 2024.

Let’s pause for a moment and contemplate the potential ripple effect.

Having dawdled and missed its chance when the game turned professional in the 1990s, the RFU would be back in control. The national head coach, as in Ireland, would have a far greater say regarding his players’ workload. The whole complexion of squad announcements would also change. There would still be scope for rising newcomers such as, in this instance, the excellent Harlequins wing Cadan Murley, but the majority of players would be on annual or multi-year deals with the union.

Progress? If you are a cash-strapped club forced to pay top dollar for internationals who are seldom available, it is a double-edged sword. Your wage bill goes down but you also lose your prime marketing asset for even bigger chunks of the season. A more sustainable but less star-studded Premiership? It could yet unfold that way.

When it was put to Eddie Jones that the job of England head coach might just be about to become simpler, there was absolutely no air-punching. There was a very simple reason for that: if anyone is going to benefit from a changing contractual landscape it will be his successors.

“It’s got nothing to do with me, mate,” he said, aware of the comments on the subject by his chief executive, Bill Sweeney, on Sunday. “In the next 12 months, as Bill suggested, there may be changes and I look forward to seeing them from afar.”

The talented Willis, though, could theoretically be a guinea pig, assuming another club do not snap him up before the RFU gets its wallet out.

When fit, there is no question the flanker ranks as one of England’s top 30-odd players; as a specialist in breakdown impacts it would also make sense for him, as will now be the case, to be as fresh as possible for major tournaments.

“He’s not training with his club, obviously, so we’ve got some of our staff working with him to make sure he’s in the best physical condition,” Jones said.

Sure, but what about the mental stress? Like every other Wasps employee – and seriously good people such as their enlightened director of rugby, Lee Blackett, deserve particular sympathy – Willis would not be human if he did not feel completely gutted right now. Jones, though, has made clear that, from the management’s perspective, moping is not an option.

“Jack’s got to get on with it. Everyone feels for Wasps – I feel for their players, their staff and their fans – but good players make the most of it. He’s got a history of resilience and he’s a good, tough kid. There’s an opportunity for him to be in his absolutely best physical condition.”

The wider implications for English rugby of the Premiership’s continuing meltdown, even so, cannot, be totally overlooked. First Worcester, now Wasps. A bumpy domestic backdrop and a wage freeze might also tempt more players to move abroad, putting pressure on the RFU’s policy that only Premiership-based players are eligible for England. If Maro Itoje, say, can earn twice as much at Racing 92 as at home, the RFU might have to start looking at post-World Cup overseas “sabbaticals”, like the one New Zealand have just granted Ardie Savea.

In the shorter-term, though, Jones is putting on a brave face. The majority of competitions, in his experience, endure growing pains at some stage. “These cycles happen all the time in sport, so I wouldn’t get too depressed or upset about it.”

Maybe, but for Wasps’ England hopefuls such as Joe Launchbury, Paolo Odogwu, Gabriel Oghre or (the currently injured) Alfie Barbeary, that will be no real consolation.

Surely, too, the off-field upheaval will not enhance his squad’s collective mood, with many of their best mates suddenly unemployed? “I’m not sure how much that reverberates through the players’ heads,” Jones said. “All the best players are pretty single-minded. I’m sure at times they have conversations over double espressos but, generally speaking, I think their focus will be on what they can do.”

Henry Slade, Joe Marchant and Elliot Daly – to name but three omitted centres – will certainly be feeling seriously focused. England still have Owen Farrell and Manu Tuilagi, backed up by Guy Porter and young Will Joseph, but Tuilagi and Slade feels like a potent combination when they are fully fit and firing.

The head coach did have some consoling words for Slade after his summer shoulder operation – “He’s a good player, Henry, and there’s no doubt he’ll be back in the squad … we just want to see him have some consistent form for his club” – but, ultimately, Jones sees squad sessions as a more reliable proving ground than club games. “You can never use the club game as a barometer of what the Test game’s going to be like. That’s fool’s gold, because it’s different.”

Which, from an RFU perspective, brings us right back to where we started. Central contracts, anyone?

Andywasp50

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 178
  • Wasps Rugby Fan
    • View Profile
Re: Guardian - Kitson's Blog (a must read)
« Reply #2 on: October 18, 2022, 10:41:54 AM »
That first piece by Kitson is excellent.

BrackenandMacken

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 116
  • Wasps Rugby Fan
    • View Profile
Re: Guardian - Kitson's Blog (a must read)
« Reply #3 on: October 18, 2022, 10:57:11 AM »
The TV deal against the French league is startling.

Makes you wonder why the English clubs feel they have to compete with the French clubs for players. Comparing the Top 14 and the Premiership is like the reversal of the premier league football and Ligue 1.

One league is incredibly popular, great crowds and huge engagement nationally. The other is reliant and dictated by mega rich owners of a few clubs.

Must say I’m non plussed about the future of the premiership, I’m working out which Top14 team I will follow going forward. All I want in English rugby is for Launch to win a trophy as my god that giant of a man deserves it.

InBetweenWasp

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1011
  • Wasps Rugby Fan
    • View Profile
Re: Guardian - Kitson's Blog (a must read)
« Reply #4 on: October 18, 2022, 11:15:54 AM »
I'm a bit surprised they wouldn't test out 'central contracting' with Launch as well as Jack.  Joe might not be in the squad but is up there with the options.  Is a big lump, excellent in maul defence.  Has had issues with injuries, why not get him and Jack solely conditioned and focussed on England with no games in line for a while.

Peej

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 862
  • Wasps Rugby Fan
    • View Profile
Re: Guardian - Kitson's Blog (a must read)
« Reply #5 on: October 19, 2022, 04:22:50 PM »
I'm a bit surprised they wouldn't test out 'central contracting' with Launch as well as Jack.  Joe might not be in the squad but is up there with the options.  Is a big lump, excellent in maul defence.  Has had issues with injuries, why not get him and Jack solely conditioned and focussed on England with no games in line for a while.

That's why. He is on the way out internationally, so why would he be part of the experiment?