I have said it before, but creating a 10 team league and stopping promotion and relegation will kill off the professional game.
Maybe it needs to die? The professional game I mean.
I think it does. Certainly in England and Wales. A 10 team league would be an unmitigated disaster.
12 teams didn't work
14 teams probably wouldn't work, 10 teams likely won't either.
The problem is that there's not enough money coming into the game to cover the salaries the players want (deserve).
Everyone involved is looking to other sports to try to find the solution.
The football model is unlikely to work for English rugby because France has already got a huge step ahead of us there. The only way to beat that is to throw more money at it than the French are.... And that just doesn't look like working.
So ring fencing a smaller league of similar in essence to NFL.
The same teams regularly play each other (albeit with a bit of variety)... But it's clearly such a different model with their college system and draft to ensure the weaker teams get strengthened.
Ultimately the most likely method for long term success is for players to play for peanuts. Unfortunately that likely means the quality of the game drops and we're even less likely to get good sponsorship.
I'm coming around to the idea that a European league is the only way for English rugby, but only if the French buy into it, and I can't see that happening