The Dilemma Around Kurtley Beale

Please follow and like us:
24
Kurtley Beale

Kurtley Beale – Once a Wasp?

Kurtley Beale

Kurtley Beale was one of the biggest signings of the year when the deal was struck for him to come to Wasps, and when he ruptured his patella tendon within hours of the deal being finalised it seemed like a disaster. But his recovery went well and he arrived in Coventry on time, and within less time than anyone could have expected made his debut and scored his first try in black and gold (Match Report).

His signing undeniably went a long way to consoling Wasps’ fans over the loss of Charles Piutau and his brother Siale who had made such a positive impression and rapidly become firm favourites. We all knew they were short term signings, but I suspect I wasn’t the only person who, deep down inside, truly hoped they’d choose to stay. But move on they did, and the addition of Kurtley Beale meant it wasn’t that big a blow.

However because of first his contractual commitments, and second the demands of recovering from a potentially career ending injury meant he wasn’t going to be available until later in the season, so for a while we were going to have to make do with neither Charles Piutau, nor Kurtley Beale.

Thankfully for Wasps we have a player who could easily be described as one of the most under-rated backs in the Premiership. Rob Miller.

Without a world class star at 15 Miller took the opportunity to prove his worth. His solidity under the high ball, his aggressive running, his offloads, and his kicking out of hand meant he rapidly took all the urgency out of the wait for Beale to arrive. It didn’t really seem to matter. And with Jimmy Gopperth able to drop back to cover 15 should it be needed, and in one memorable game the youngster Piers O’Connor taking the 15 shirt to allow Miller to play at 10 it seemed our stock of fullbacks was at an all time high.

But then it was announced that Elliot Daly was expected to make the most of his England career playing at 15, leading to the suggestion that maybe he should play there for Wasps, and as if that wasn’t enough Willie le Roux finally arrived from South Africa to start his time at Wasps.

An Enviable Dilemma

So now Dai Young is in the somewhat enviable position of having to choose between Wasps’ own successful fullback in Miller, two of the best fullbacks in the world in Willie le Roux and Kurtley Beale, and the precocious talent of Daly.

Of course Beale can also play at 10, Daly can play at 11, 12, 13, 14, or 15, Le Roux can play at 11, 14, or 15, and both Miller and Gopperth can seeming play anywhere they feel like, so it isn’t that big a problem. The difficult thing is deciding who to put where. Can any team in the world seriously decide to leave out a player of the calibre of any of the potential options?

And if, for the sake of argument, we do decide to play le Roux at 15, do we then play Beale in the centre? And if we do that do we leave out Daly or Gopperth? How about the equally impressive Eastmond? Perhaps we bump Gopperth to 10, but then we leave out Cipriani.

Maybe the answer is to put le Roux on the wing, but then do we leave out Wade? Surely not. But Halai has proved his worth time and time again over the last couple of seasons, and Bassett has made some seriously impressive improvements in his game and would be a clear starter in almost any other team, so which one of them do we drop?

And that doesn’t even begin to discuss the relative merits of players like Macken, Leiua, or Armitage, all of whom could and have slotted in seamlessly when needed to.

The Rumour Mill

So when the rumour mill started up recently saying that Beale was likely to be leaving Wasps at the end of the season I suspect I wasn’t the only person who wasn’t desperately disappointed. Don’t get me wrong, I’d love him to stay, a player of Kurtley Beale’s ability is always going to benefit a team. He’s got a definite x-factor on the pitch and the ability to change the game in a flash. But if he did decide that moving to the UK was an experiment that hadn’t worked out for him I don’t think it would be the end of the world.

I for one wouldn’t blame him if he wanted to move back to Australia. It must have been a hugely traumatic time for him, moving to the other side of the world on the back of a serious injury. And a move that was definitely not supported by the rugby establishment in Australia. Michael Cheika has made it very clear that he did not approve, that he thought it was a mistake for Beale personally, and a damaging move for the Wallabies. That can’t have made it any easier for him, and if he does move back I’d put the blame firmly at Cheika’s door.

I don’t agree that it is a bad move for Beale to play here. I think broadening his horizons, experiencing a different style of play and a new tournament can only benefit him as a player, and getting to know and play regularly against a lot of internationals he will face in the gold shirt of Australia can’t be a bad thing. I think that all of Cheika’s comments have been based on his personal issues with not having access to Beale whenever he wanted it. Not having him in Australia can only have made it harder for Cheika to manage the international squad. But whilst he has to put his own job first, going out of his way to disrupt the career and earnings of one of his star players in order to make his own job easier is selfish at best. Kurtley Beale’s injury is an abject lesson that even the best players could end up unable to ever play again at any moment. And so sabotaging what was reported in the press as the biggest salary in world rugby is an outrageous thing to do.

That being said, it’s also being reported that Bath are also interested in signing Beale. I know it makes me as selfish and subjective as I have just accused Cheika of being, but I think that would be an unfair decision. It was Wasps that brought him to the UK and supported him through the treatment and rehabilitation for his injury, and if he then moves to another UK club within half a season I’d be upset. But not because I think Wasps will suffer noticeably.

With le Roux, Miller, and all the other embarrassment of riches we have in our back line I think we’ll be just fine.

Please follow and like us:
24

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *